Memo Stirs Old vs. New Media War
Buzz it
The weekend is over and it’s time to get back to business and talk about what turns the Bloke’s crank - blogging that is. Rathergate is still making the news:
WITH THE revelation that CBS News aired what appear to be forged memos as part of its “60 Minutes II” story on President Bush’s Vietnam-era National Guard service, the “memogate” story shifted from Bush vs. Kerry to old media vs. new media. Hours after the show aired, questions about the authenticity of the memos, purportedly written by Bush’s then-superior officer Jerry Killian in 1973, surfaced on right-of-center blogs (short for “weblogs”). By the next day, those questions were also being posed by the mainstream media such as The Washington Post and ABC News.A defining moment in the Battle of the Media came when former CBS News executive Jonathan Klein said in a television appearance defending the story, “You couldn’t have a starker contrast between the multiple layers of checks and balances and a guy sitting in his living room in his pajamas writing.”
To many denizens of the blogosphere, this comment exemplified the arrogance, elitism, and cluelessness of the “old media.” And let’s face it, the bloggers had every reason to gloat when, shortly after Klein’s statement, new information surfaced suggesting that those vaunted checks and balances at CBS News had failed rather miserably in this case. According to a report at the ABC News website, some of the experts CBS consulted prior to airing the story warned the producers that they had doubts about the documents’ authenticity.
This is hardly the first time the “old media” have suffered a black eye in recent years. Journalists at some of the most esteemed print publications — Jayson Blair at The New York Times, Pulitzer Prize finalist Jack Kelley at USA Today, Stephen Glass at The New Republic — have been exposed as fabricators. Dateline NBC has been caught rigging a truck for a crash test to simulate the desired results.
Right now, the bloggers are in an understandably self-congratulatory mood. The Internet, they argue, has led to a true democratization of the media, toppling the old elites; the competition from other pajama-clad guys and gals provides plenty of checks and balances.
Yet a few words of caution are in order. First, as veteran blogger Glenn Reynolds of Instapundit points out at the Tech Central Station website, the “big media” still do virtually all of the actual news-gathering; a lone wolf with a home computer and a strong opinion simply doesn’t have the resources to compete in that arena. In that sense, the blogosphere feeds off the mainstream media — though it often provides excellent commentary, analysis, and fact-checking. Reynolds believes the relationship between “new” and “old” media is symbiotic more than adversarial.
Second, media hoaxes and forgeries have been exposed before the Internet. (Remember the “Hitler diaries” published in 1983?) Assuming that the Killian memos are indeed fake, it’s quite likely that the forgeries would have been exposed even without the intrepid bloggers, though later rather than sooner.
Third, while competition is a wonderful thing, a firestorm in the blogosphere can generate more heat — and smoke — than light. As I tried to follow the early debate on the CBS memos, I was utterly confused by the cacophony of agenda-driven charges and countercharges, insults, and clashing pronouncements by self-styled experts whose credentials had to be taken on faith. The pro-Bush blogs shrieked that the incriminating documents were obvious computer-created fakes; the anti-Bush blogs shrieked that, beyond any doubt, typewriters capable of producing these memos were available in the 1970s. No offense to the upstart blogs, but what finally settled my doubts was reporting by mainstream media such as ABC News and The Washington Post.
This is not to say that the mainstream media are or were agenda-free. While conservative charges of liberal media bias have often been exaggerated, most people working in the establishment media do share certain politically liberal assumptions that probably affect, however unconsciously, their decision to give credence to particular experts or facts.
In the past, the danger was that the “big media” with their unspoken biases could exert too much unchecked and unbalanced influence over public opinion. Today, the danger is that some people will choke on the overabundance of facts and interpretations, while others will withdraw into a comfortable niche, exposing themselves only to journalism that feeds their prejudices.
Even if the CBS memos are conclusively exposed as forgeries, many readers of left-wing blogs will continue to believe they are real — just as many of their counterparts on the right would continue to question the documents’ authenticity if the shoe were on the other foot.
*Although it is true the blogosphere is fed primarily by mainstream news, Blog Bloke would like to point out this story was the contrary, and a new “checks and balances” power has emerged. Jonathan Klein take note: there’s a new sherrif in town and it’s called the blogosphere - and we’re watching. Oh, and for your information sir the Bloke writes in his study wearing skivvies (I wouldn’t dwell on that too long if I were you. 
More at News Blog.
Filed under: Miscellaneous Blog Tips
What Next? Read More Tips From BLOGBloke:
Subscribe here to the Better Tips Newsfeed! 
Follow @BLOGBloke on Twitter for Social Media Tips & News!
Opinions? (click here to jump to the comments form)
Video
.gif){kind=small}
If their was ever a President in my lifetime that I think was totally incompetent its George Bush. It will take our country years and years to correct the mistakes and excess of his regime.
Unfortunately Obama will own the economy that Bush left us very soon.
[
Reply..]
Thanks Dev! http://bit.ly/2pkIJb
awesome site brotha http://bit.ly/1jshln
@Gaia Herbs, some look like downtown Las Vegas in the evening. http://bit.ly/2ub7iQ
@Gaia Herbs, some look like downtown Las Vegas in the evening. http://bit.ly/2ub7iQ
@CFI, @hospitalera … my head was spinning when I wrote it
http://bit.ly/1CQix9
RT @BLOGBloke: 10 Reasons Why I Don’t Like Your Blog http://bit.ly/2TRLSx
10 Reasons Why I Don’t Like Your Blog http://bit.ly/2TRLSx
@Humayon, if you are just a blogspot user then you don't need to bother with dns settings. But I still recommend ge… http://bit.ly/1fDYre
@hari saryono, I wrote an article about why we should not play into terrorists hands by linking to these horrific v… http://bit.ly/2aTKBw
@InternetMarketingMentor, here's another analogy for you. Your blog is your permanent home and social networks are … http://bit.ly/4hZtE
Optimize Your Blog - Making Your Blog Search Engine Friendly http://bit.ly/4A9Go5
@Mike, glad you liked it. If you're serious about blogging then Wordpress is the way to go. http://bit.ly/33GQUp
via @BLOGBloke: Hi There! Thanks for following. Why not ask me a question or for more blog tips visit http://tinyurl.com/5zjajb. Cheers!
@Michelle, you do not need a subdomain for it to work. A subdomain is also a bad idea for SEO. You need to go over … http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
@Justin Gill .. thanks for saying so Justin. It always feels great to hear from another happy customer.
Cheers! http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
blog hating at http://www.blogbloke.com/10-reasons-why-i-dont-like-your-blog was just pinged to 91 Services!
@Kay, I never thought of it that way http://bit.ly/1CQix9
@humglum http://www.blogbloke.com/moving-wordpress-blogger/ basically… no. doesnt look like it'll happen.
@BLOGBloke,
I decided to get rid of the Blogger redirect as the redirect via modification to .htaccess works, t… http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
@Michelle, redirect speeds will depend on the blog host's servers and your internet connection. You only need to pa… http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
@drugi, you mean "you can please some of the people all of the time and all of the people some of the time, but you… http://bit.ly/4CvJh7
Finding Your Blog Voice http://bit.ly/5LD5kQ
@zarazek, don't get your domains through Wordpress. Use GoDaddy or something similar. http://bit.ly/1fDYre
Saw an advertisement for Moving Blogger to Wordpress Service. Why not save your money and read my free guide? http://bit.ly/6rFYFE They do
hmm.. informative )) http://bit.ly/6krJX6
I should notify my girlfriend about your post. http://bit.ly/6iqFfC
hello everybody, how are you all doing.i am liking this web sight i might start staying on it more. me i stay sick … http://bit.ly/6krJX6
@Cdathy Tibbles, I host images on my wordpress.com account. Let me know it goes. I always like to hear from happy c… http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
@BLOGBloke, Yeh, I had a domain from a different comapny but Wordpress said I still had pay them to be able to link… http://bit.ly/1fDYre
@zarazek, so if I understand you correctly your blog was being hosted by Wordpress and then they insisted on chargi… http://bit.ly/1fDYre
I'm very happy with the refinements I made to the blog. What do you think? http://www.blogbloke.com/
How to Produce Your Own Podcast http://ff.im/-dm32o
"10 Reasons Why Twitter Is So Popular" ( http://bit.ly/8CM5gX )
Updated my Blokester Buttons for 2010. Grab yours now .. http://www.blogbloke.com/introducing-new-blokester-buttons/
How to Make Professional Podcast Videos for Your Blog (Vlog) http://bit.ly/7EHvN8
RT @projournalist: How to Make Professional Podcast Videos for Your Blog (Vlog) http://bit.ly/7EHvN8
RT @journtoolbox RT @projournalist: How to Make Professional Podcast Videos for Your Blog (Vlog) http://bit.ly/7EHvN8
@BLOGBloke - really ok - am trying to pull off this from your blog http://bit.ly/5Zv5kW (thank you so much for documenting this - it rocks)
@BLOGBloke - do you think I could use this service to redirect or park my domain like you mentioned in http://bit.ly/5Zv5kW
Great tutorial on migrating your blog from #blogger to #wordpress. http://bit.ly/Nlr2k
@10timesone .. have you read this http://www.blogbloke.com/migrating-redirecting-blogger-wordpress-htaccess-apache-best-method/
@FijiLomalagi my email is at the bottom of my blog http://www.blogbloke.com/
@Kwame, you will have to play around with the Apache code .. http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
@Ankit_A see if this helps.. http://bit.ly/Nlr2k
@drewmillikin My technical skills are limited, but I found this post to be very helpful: http://bit.ly/7LY764. My advice: pull the trigger.
@Adam Johnson .. it was my pleasure and glad it worked for you .. http://bit.ly/5Z3vbE
@gopmommy Your domain name redirection is done on your hosting service. Check this tutorial http://is.gd/8TXkI
@stepfanieb Check #6. http://bit.ly/Nlr2k
RT @BLOGBlokeTips How to Make Professional Podcast Videos for Your Blog (Vlog) http://bit.ly/2JgxLd